SQQ¶

h2h-summary.csv and h2h-clavis-cages.csv are copied from HaoZeke/seams-core branch bench/h2h-mdapy-pyscal3-vesin at 323bfd3872e726b3fa384a67c6b1bedf627ce6a0 (https://github.com/HaoZeke/seams-core/blob/323bfd3872e726b3fa384a67c6b1bedf627ce6a0/benchmarks/h2h-summary.csv). h2h-sqq.csv and h2h-sqq-agree.csv are copied from HaoZeke/seams-core branch bench/h2h-sqq at c7f71310f27c5ce62d11e97fd82f9757fa4e8628 (https://github.com/HaoZeke/seams-core/blob/c7f71310f27c5ce62d11e97fd82f9757fa4e8628/benchmarks/h2h-sqq.csv). docs/render_comparisons.py writes the Comparisons tables from these files.

On the 4096-molecule TIP4P/2005 frame the edges and rings match: O-O edges 10495 = 10495; 4-rings 1758 = 1758; 5-rings 2763 = 2763; 6-rings 2485 = 2485. The chordless census is the like-for-like ice row. At one thread the SQQ/d-SEAMS ratio is 32.015 (version 2.14.0/0.5.8, threads 1, n=8, cores 1) and at eight threads it is 114.971 (version 2.14.0/0.5.8, threads 8, n=8, cores 8). The whole-tool ratio is CHILL+ against SQQ’s ice stage. At one thread it is 511.905 (version 2.14.0/0.5.8, threads 1, n=8, cores 1) and at eight threads it is 579.849 (version 2.14.0/0.5.8, threads 8, n=8, cores 8).

Agreement on the TIP4P/2005 frame. The version is the build named on every timing row. This census is not itself a timed run. The other frames are in the block below.

version

frame

molecules

quantity

d-SEAMS

SQQ

both

agreement

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

O-O edges

10495

10495

10495

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

4-rings

1758

1758

1758

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

5-rings

2763

2763

2763

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

6-rings

2485

2485

2485

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice label (merged)

4

1129

2969

0.724854

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS primitive 6-rings

1075

1129

4042

0.986816

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

chordless 6-rings

4045

4045

4045

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS chordless 6-rings

1129

1129

4096

1.000000

Full SQQ agreement

version

frame

molecules

quantity

d-SEAMS

SQQ

both

agreement

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

O-O edges

8192

8192

8192

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

4-rings

0

0

0

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

5-rings

0

0

0

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

6-rings

8192

8192

8192

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

ice label (merged)

4096

4096

4096

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS primitive 6-rings

4096

4096

4096

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

chordless 6-rings

8192

8192

8192

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS chordless 6-rings

4096

4096

4096

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

O-O edges

8192

8192

8192

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

4-rings

0

0

0

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

5-rings

0

0

0

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

6-rings

8192

8192

8192

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

ice label (merged)

4096

4096

4096

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS primitive 6-rings

4096

4096

4096

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

chordless 6-rings

8192

8192

8192

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS chordless 6-rings

4096

4096

4096

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

O-O edges

9579

9579

9579

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

4-rings

1315

1315

1315

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

5-rings

3190

3190

3190

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

6-rings

3207

3207

3207

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

ice label (merged)

81

1851

2301

0.561768

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS primitive 6-rings

1827

1851

4071

0.993896

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

chordless 6-rings

4592

4592

4592

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS chordless 6-rings

1851

1851

4096

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

O-O edges

10495

10495

10495

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

4-rings

1758

1758

1758

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

5-rings

2763

2763

2763

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

6-rings

2485

2485

2485

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice label (merged)

4

1129

2969

0.724854

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS primitive 6-rings

1075

1129

4042

0.986816

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

chordless 6-rings

4045

4045

4045

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS chordless 6-rings

1129

1129

4096

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

O-O edges

221184

221184

221184

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

4-rings

0

0

0

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

5-rings

0

0

0

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

6-rings

221184

221184

221184

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

ice label (merged)

110592

110592

110592

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS primitive 6-rings

110592

110592

110592

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

chordless 6-rings

221184

221184

221184

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS chordless 6-rings

110592

110592

110592

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

O-O edges

221184

221184

221184

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

4-rings

0

0

0

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

5-rings

0

0

0

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

6-rings

221184

221184

221184

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

ice label (merged)

110592

110592

110592

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS primitive 6-rings

110592

110592

110592

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

chordless 6-rings

221184

221184

221184

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS chordless 6-rings

110592

110592

110592

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

O-O edges

259187

259186

259186

0.999996

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

4-rings

34097

34098

34097

0.999971

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

5-rings

86218

86217

86217

0.999988

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

6-rings

85092

85094

85092

0.999976

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

ice label (merged)

2509

50121

62148

0.561957

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS primitive 6-rings

49462

50121

109800

0.992839

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

chordless 6-rings

123915

123917

123915

0.999984

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS chordless 6-rings

50120

50121

110591

0.999991

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

O-O edges

509

509

509

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

4-rings

273

273

273

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

5-rings

34

34

34

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

6-rings

167

167

167

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

ice label (merged)

0

206

44

0.176000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS primitive 6-rings

190

206

234

0.936000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

chordless 6-rings

203

203

203

1.000000

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

ice label, SQQ rule on d-SEAMS chordless 6-rings

206

206

250

1.000000

Timing on the TIP4P/2005 frame. Every row names the version, the thread count, the repeat count and the core count.

version

frame

molecules

operation

threads

cores

n

d-SEAMS ms

SQQ ms

SQQ/d-SEAMS

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

rings

1

1

8

22.6026

1054.3846

46.649

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

rings

8

8

8

8.2165

1056.0863

128.532

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice

1

1

8

1.7860

914.2565

511.905

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice

8

8

8

1.5802

916.2551

579.849

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice-primitive

1

1

8

23.3003

914.2565

39.238

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice-primitive

8

8

8

8.4130

916.2551

108.910

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice-chordless

1

1

8

28.5570

914.2565

32.015

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice-chordless

8

8

8

7.9694

916.2551

114.971

Full SQQ timings

version

frame

molecules

operation

threads

cores

n

d-SEAMS ms

SQQ ms

SQQ/d-SEAMS

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

rings

1

1

8

4.8943

608.2828

124.285

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

rings

8

8

8

3.8063

624.0049

163.941

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

rings

1

1

8

4.7568

650.1232

136.674

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

rings

8

8

8

3.4015

653.5030

192.121

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

rings

1

1

8

18.5027

859.8321

46.471

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

rings

8

8

8

7.4242

872.3099

117.495

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

rings

1

1

8

22.6026

1054.3846

46.649

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

rings

8

8

8

8.2165

1056.0863

128.532

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

rings

1

1

8

124.7942

18027.8164

144.460

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

rings

8

8

8

60.2947

18237.9581

302.480

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

rings

1

1

8

132.6909

19406.3696

146.252

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

rings

8

8

8

66.2536

19951.3945

301.137

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

rings

1

1

8

556.8878

27271.9587

48.972

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

rings

8

8

8

143.1103

26157.0888

182.776

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

rings

1

1

8

0.5240

24.6406

47.026

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

rings

8

8

8

0.5448

23.8880

43.849

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

ice

1

1

8

1.0146

555.6662

547.684

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

ice

8

8

8

0.7948

562.4742

707.715

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

ice

1

1

8

0.8901

596.3612

669.965

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

ice

8

8

8

0.5976

611.5652

1023.305

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

ice

1

1

8

1.6919

731.4697

432.349

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

ice

8

8

8

0.9527

753.1118

790.492

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice

1

1

8

1.7860

914.2565

511.905

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice

8

8

8

1.5802

916.2551

579.849

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

ice

1

1

8

27.3869

16937.4997

618.451

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

ice

8

8

8

11.7965

16973.4206

1438.849

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

ice

1

1

8

23.2432

17753.8721

763.830

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

ice

8

8

8

11.1758

18366.3053

1643.400

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

ice

1

1

8

68.9490

24022.3130

348.407

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

ice

8

8

8

18.7627

22649.1823

1207.136

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

ice

1

1

8

0.1027

19.3486

188.400

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

ice

8

8

8

0.1778

19.3255

108.685

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

ice-primitive

1

1

8

5.3524

555.6662

103.816

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

ice-primitive

8

8

8

3.9073

562.4742

143.955

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

ice-primitive

1

1

8

5.0394

596.3612

118.341

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

ice-primitive

8

8

8

3.4238

611.5652

178.622

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

ice-primitive

1

1

8

19.1844

731.4697

38.128

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

ice-primitive

8

8

8

7.6982

753.1118

97.830

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice-primitive

1

1

8

23.3003

914.2565

39.238

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice-primitive

8

8

8

8.4130

916.2551

108.910

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

ice-primitive

1

1

8

139.2249

16937.4997

121.656

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

ice-primitive

8

8

8

72.4419

16973.4206

234.304

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

ice-primitive

1

1

8

133.1792

17753.8721

133.308

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

ice-primitive

8

8

8

80.8671

18366.3053

227.117

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

ice-primitive

1

1

8

641.1424

24022.3130

37.468

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

ice-primitive

8

8

8

155.6361

22649.1823

145.527

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

ice-primitive

1

1

8

0.5219

19.3486

37.072

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

ice-primitive

8

8

8

1.0443

19.3255

18.506

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

ice-chordless

1

1

8

4.3828

555.6662

126.784

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-4096

4096

ice-chordless

8

8

8

1.3885

562.4742

405.102

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

ice-chordless

1

1

8

4.4174

596.3612

135.003

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-4096

4096

ice-chordless

8

8

8

1.6660

611.5652

367.089

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

ice-chordless

1

1

8

20.6070

731.4697

35.496

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-4096

4096

ice-chordless

8

8

8

6.9055

753.1118

109.060

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice-chordless

1

1

8

28.5570

914.2565

32.015

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p2005-4096

4096

ice-chordless

8

8

8

7.9694

916.2551

114.971

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

ice-chordless

1

1

8

98.9570

16937.4997

171.160

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ic-110592

110592

ice-chordless

8

8

8

21.0108

16973.4206

807.843

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

ice-chordless

1

1

8

99.2178

17753.8721

178.938

2.14.0/0.5.8

Ih-110592

110592

ice-chordless

8

8

8

21.8655

18366.3053

839.968

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

ice-chordless

1

1

8

645.0077

24022.3130

37.243

2.14.0/0.5.8

mw-liquid-110592

110592

ice-chordless

8

8

8

86.6990

22649.1823

261.239

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

ice-chordless

1

1

8

0.5016

19.3486

38.575

2.14.0/0.5.8

tip4p-o-250

250

ice-chordless

8

8

8

0.7695

19.3255

25.116