Head-to-head summary

h2h-summary.csv and h2h-clavis-cages.csv are copied from HaoZeke/seams-core branch bench/h2h-mdapy-pyscal3-vesin at 323bfd3872e726b3fa384a67c6b1bedf627ce6a0 (https://github.com/HaoZeke/seams-core/blob/323bfd3872e726b3fa384a67c6b1bedf627ce6a0/benchmarks/h2h-summary.csv). h2h-sqq.csv and h2h-sqq-agree.csv are copied from HaoZeke/seams-core branch bench/h2h-sqq at c7f71310f27c5ce62d11e97fd82f9757fa4e8628 (https://github.com/HaoZeke/seams-core/blob/c7f71310f27c5ce62d11e97fd82f9757fa4e8628/benchmarks/h2h-sqq.csv). docs/render_comparisons.py writes the Comparisons tables from these files.

Each row is one record of h2h-summary.csv. The version, thread count, repeat count n and core count are the CSV columns. The agreement text for every row is in the block below.

comparator

version

operation

molecules

threads

cores

n

d-SEAMS ms

other ms

ratio

verdict

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

chill_plus

1

8

0

absent

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

4096

1

8

8

0.2524

1.7137

6.7902

WIN

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

4096

1

8

8

0.2809

2.9465

10.4886

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

4096

1

8

8

0.7256

4.6527

6.4123

WIN

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

4096

1

8

8

0.7415

3.5078

4.7306

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

4096

1

8

8

0.7184

2.6670

3.7122

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0

cna

4096

1

8

1

correctness

OVITO

2.14.0

cna

4096

1

8

1

correctness

OVITO

2.14.0

cna

4096

1

8

1

correctness

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

4096

1

8

8

0.7334

189.4989

258.3907

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

4096

1

8

8

0.7255

4.5952

6.3335

WIN

freud

2.14.0

rings

4096

1

8

0

absent

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

4096

1

8

8

0.7306

4.7155

6.4542

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

4096

1

8

8

4.5301

15.8206

3.4923

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

4096

1

8

8

0.7264

105.0304

144.5805

WIN

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

4096

1

8

8

0.7230

121.5863

168.1621

WIN

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

4096

1

8

8

4.5552

56.9215

12.4961

WIN

cycless

2.14.0/0.7

rings

4096

1

8

8

5.0379

12678.2659

2516.5770

WIN

IRA

2.14.0/2.2.0

shape

4096

1

8

8

0.7481

1302.6695

1741.2294

WIN

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

4096

1

8

0

DNF

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

110592

1

8

8

6.4962

45.9557

7.0742

WIN

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

110592

1

8

8

6.4788

91.8476

14.1766

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

110592

1

8

8

18.7583

108.5550

5.7870

WIN

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

110592

1

8

8

18.7787

99.5513

5.3013

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

110592

1

8

8

18.5351

56.9564

3.0729

WIN

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

110592

1

8

8

21.8284

4855.0064

222.4168

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

110592

1

8

8

18.4099

113.8680

6.1851

WIN

freud

2.14.0

rings

110592

1

8

0

absent

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

110592

1

8

8

20.7730

136.5008

6.5711

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

110592

1

8

8

119.4383

503.1571

4.2127

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

110592

1

8

8

21.0405

2903.9205

138.0160

WIN

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

110592

1

8

8

19.2551

3006.8135

156.1569

WIN

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

110592

1

8

8

116.2389

1327.4966

11.4204

WIN

IRA

2.2.0

shape

110592

1

8

0

DNF

cycless

2.14.0/0.7

rings

110592

1

8

8

136.3856

341558.2557

2504.3573

WIN

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

110592

1

8

0

DNF

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

884736

1

8

8

82.4432

1140.5612

13.8345

WIN

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

884736

1

8

8

102.7091

930.3372

9.0580

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

884736

1

8

8

237.0502

1039.0684

4.3833

WIN

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

884736

1

8

8

237.9653

927.0447

3.8957

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

884736

1

8

8

203.1011

585.3079

2.8819

WIN

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

884736

1

8

8

255.8396

38381.2306

150.0207

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

884736

1

8

8

208.1052

1007.4027

4.8408

WIN

freud

2.14.0

rings

884736

1

8

0

absent

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

884736

1

8

8

248.1369

1136.5466

4.5803

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

884736

1

8

8

1046.5149

4542.0060

4.3401

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

884736

1

8

8

259.8032

23247.5896

89.4815

WIN

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

884736

1

8

8

240.7382

23208.5792

96.4059

WIN

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

884736

1

8

8

1032.6158

13012.7347

12.6017

WIN

cycless

0.7

rings

884736

1

8

0

DNF

IRA

2.2.0

shape

884736

1

8

0

DNF

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

884736

1

8

0

DNF

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

chill_plus

8

8

0

absent

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

4096

8

8

8

0.2509

0.5761

2.2961

WIN

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

4096

8

8

8

0.3054

0.8688

2.8444

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

4096

8

8

8

0.5273

0.8488

1.6098

WIN

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

4096

8

8

8

0.3900

1.9000

4.8712

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

4096

8

8

8

0.5076

0.5913

1.1649

WIN

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

4096

8

8

8

0.2783

24.0122

86.2705

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

4096

8

8

8

0.4711

4.5363

9.6285

WIN

freud

2.14.0

rings

4096

8

8

0

absent

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

4096

8

8

8

0.5566

1.9548

3.5122

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

4096

8

8

8

2.6129

17.6346

6.7491

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

4096

8

8

8

0.5204

28.3374

54.4549

WIN

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

4096

8

8

8

0.6326

109.1420

172.5345

WIN

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

4096

8

8

8

2.2476

12.5984

5.6052

WIN

cycless

2.14.0/0.7

rings

4096

8

8

8

2.9191

12516.1838

4287.6594

WIN

IRA

2.14.0/2.2.0

shape

4096

8

8

8

1.2898

1299.2780

1007.3679

WIN

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

4096

8

8

0

DNF

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

110592

8

8

8

4.0501

14.9654

3.6950

WIN

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

110592

8

8

8

3.8882

31.5433

8.1125

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

110592

8

8

8

5.3935

15.2391

2.8254

WIN

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

110592

8

8

8

5.3208

18.3291

3.4448

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

110592

8

8

8

7.5892

10.3904

1.3691

WIN

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

110592

8

8

8

8.2662

613.5692

74.2262

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

110592

8

8

8

5.2050

113.8816

21.8794

WIN

freud

2.14.0

rings

110592

8

8

0

absent

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

110592

8

8

8

8.3309

29.5160

3.5430

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

110592

8

8

8

48.3409

323.8505

6.6993

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

110592

8

8

8

8.5196

387.5268

45.4867

WIN

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

110592

8

8

8

8.9858

3028.2786

337.0065

WIN

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

110592

8

8

8

47.2318

307.1093

6.5022

WIN

IRA

2.2.0

shape

110592

8

8

0

DNF

cycless

2.14.0/0.7

rings

110592

8

8

8

65.8726

337108.4778

5117.5843

WIN

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

110592

8

8

0

DNF

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

884736

8

8

8

41.3136

209.6075

5.0736

WIN

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

884736

8

8

8

49.5928

343.2560

6.9215

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

884736

8

8

8

71.0785

149.8983

2.1089

WIN

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

884736

8

8

8

71.7527

177.4625

2.4733

WIN

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

884736

8

8

8

66.4798

115.4407

1.7365

WIN

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

884736

8

8

8

59.6748

4823.9120

80.8367

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

884736

8

8

8

59.4890

1008.0481

16.9451

WIN

freud

2.14.0

rings

884736

8

8

0

absent

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

884736

8

8

8

62.1147

262.3612

4.2238

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

884736

8

8

8

484.2037

2917.3354

6.0250

WIN

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

884736

8

8

8

63.6214

3062.3280

48.1336

WIN

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

884736

8

8

8

91.1466

23631.1588

259.2655

WIN

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

884736

8

8

8

476.9637

2967.7415

6.2222

WIN

cycless

0.7

rings

884736

8

8

0

DNF

IRA

2.2.0

shape

884736

8

8

0

DNF

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

884736

8

8

0

DNF

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

46

1

8

8

0.5796

50.3899

86.9321

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

46

8

8

8

0.5947

50.2893

84.5632

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

368

1

8

8

3.7222

297.6070

79.9538

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

368

8

8

8

2.9243

297.9639

101.8907

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

136

1

8

8

1.4924

68.3007

45.7666

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

136

8

8

8

1.5655

68.2571

43.6016

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

1088

1

8

8

10.7150

697.6882

65.1132

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

1088

8

8

8

4.7284

697.7931

147.5752

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

110160

1

8

8

955.8314

61962.4841

64.8257

WIN

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

110160

8

8

8

303.0753

61956.9697

204.4277

WIN

Full head-to-head records, including the agreement text

comparator

version

operation

molecules

threads

cores

n

d-SEAMS ms

other ms

ratio

verdict

agreement

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

chill_plus

1

8

0

absent

pyscal3 4.1.0 __all__ has no CHILL or CHILL+ name. common_neighbor_analysis is adaptive CNA and returns fcc, hcp, bcc, ico, and others (pyscal3/descriptors.py). diamond_structure is extended CNA. Neither is Nguyen and Molinero CHILL+. PyPI’s latest pyscal3 is this same 4.1.0.

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

4096

1

8

8

0.2524

1.7137

6.7902

WIN

pairs 8192 equal

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

4096

1

8

8

0.2809

2.9465

10.4886

WIN

pairs 8192 equal

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

4096

1

8

8

0.7256

4.6527

6.4123

WIN

q6_max_abs 4.441e-16 q6bar_max_abs 4.441e-16

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

4096

1

8

8

0.7415

3.5078

4.7306

WIN

q6_max_abs 5.551e-16 q6bar_max_abs 5.551e-16

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

4096

1

8

8

0.7184

2.6670

3.7122

WIN

labels 4096 equal q6_max_abs 4.441e-16

OVITO

2.14.0

cna

4096

1

8

1

correctness

phase Ih atoms 4096 disagree 4096. hexagonal_ice vs Other coordination 4 n=4096 (3 staggered and 1 eclipsed). Every disagreement is a CHILL+ row on a shell adaptive CNA does not name: Structure Type is only Other, FCC, HCP, BCC, or ICO (ovito/modifiers/__init__.pyi). FCC control 256/256 FCC, so the modifier is classifying. CHILL+ rows are the table in src/include/internal/bop.hpp.

OVITO

2.14.0

cna

4096

1

8

1

correctness

phase Ic atoms 4096 disagree 4096. cubic_ice vs Other coordination 4 n=4096 (4 staggered and 0 eclipsed). Every disagreement is a CHILL+ row on a shell adaptive CNA does not name: Structure Type is only Other, FCC, HCP, BCC, or ICO (ovito/modifiers/__init__.pyi). FCC control 256/256 FCC, so the modifier is classifying. CHILL+ rows are the table in src/include/internal/bop.hpp.

OVITO

2.14.0

cna

4096

1

8

1

correctness

phase liquid atoms 4096 disagree 222. hexagonal_ice vs Other coordination 4 n=1 (3 staggered and 1 eclipsed); hydrate vs Other coordination 4 n=49 (4 eclipsed and 0 staggered); interfacial_hydrate vs Other coordination 4 n=168 (3 eclipsed); interfacial_ice vs Other coordination 4 n=4 (2 staggered, or 3 staggered and 0 eclipsed). Every disagreement is a CHILL+ row on a shell adaptive CNA does not name: Structure Type is only Other, FCC, HCP, BCC, or ICO (ovito/modifiers/__init__.pyi). FCC control 256/256 FCC, so the modifier is classifying. CHILL+ rows are the table in src/include/internal/bop.hpp. Four shifted-ice waters have 12 neighbours inside 3.5 A: 690 at (4.490, 15.864, 50.345), 1673 at (16.865, 18.399, 11.795), 1675 at (15.210, 17.036, 12.464), 2304 at (16.902, 34.179, 1.355). An independent minimum-image count gives the same 12 distinct ids. The nearest pair in the frame is 0.183 A, from the Gaussian shift, not a repeated periodic image.

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

4096

1

8

8

0.7334

189.4989

258.3907

WIN

hexagonal 4096 equal rmsd_max 4.337e-08

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

4096

1

8

8

0.7255

4.5952

6.3335

WIN

labels 4096 equal; analyze_waters parses JSON built once; chill.rs is a serial loop and Cargo.toml leaves rayon commented out; 0.3.18

freud

2.14.0

rings

4096

1

8

0

absent

freud 3.6.1 modules are box, cluster, data, density, diffraction, environment, errors, interface, locality, msd, order, parallel, plot, pmft, util. There is no ring or cycle module. order.py is Steinhardt, Hexatic, SolidLiquid, Cubatic, Nematic, RotationalAutocorrelation, and ContinuousCoordination. Ramasubramani and others, Comput. Phys. Commun. 254, 107275 (2020).

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

4096

1

8

8

0.7306

4.7155

6.4542

WIN

hexagonal 4096 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

4096

1

8

8

4.5301

15.8206

3.4923

WIN

hexagons 8192 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

4096

1

8

8

0.7264

105.0304

144.5805

WIN

hexagonal 4096 equal

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

4096

1

8

8

0.7230

121.5863

168.1621

WIN

q6_max_abs 2.220e-16

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

4096

1

8

8

4.5552

56.9215

12.4961

WIN

hexagons 8192 equal

cycless

2.14.0/0.7

rings

4096

1

8

8

5.0379

12678.2659

2516.5770

WIN

hexagons 8192 equal; cycles_iter has no thread argument

IRA

2.14.0/2.2.0

shape

4096

1

8

8

0.7481

1302.6695

1741.2294

WIN

hexagonal 4096 equal

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

4096

1

8

0

DNF

512 molecules exceeded 600 s, so this size was not started

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

110592

1

8

8

6.4962

45.9557

7.0742

WIN

pairs 221184 equal

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

110592

1

8

8

6.4788

91.8476

14.1766

WIN

pairs 221184 equal

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

110592

1

8

8

18.7583

108.5550

5.7870

WIN

q6_max_abs 1.776e-15 q6bar_max_abs 1.776e-15

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

110592

1

8

8

18.7787

99.5513

5.3013

WIN

q6_max_abs 2.442e-15 q6bar_max_abs 2.442e-15

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

110592

1

8

8

18.5351

56.9564

3.0729

WIN

labels 110592 equal q6_max_abs 1.776e-15

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

110592

1

8

8

21.8284

4855.0064

222.4168

WIN

hexagonal 110592 equal rmsd_max 4.337e-08

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

110592

1

8

8

18.4099

113.8680

6.1851

WIN

labels 110592 equal; analyze_waters parses JSON built once; chill.rs is a serial loop and Cargo.toml leaves rayon commented out; 0.3.18

freud

2.14.0

rings

110592

1

8

0

absent

freud 3.6.1 modules are box, cluster, data, density, diffraction, environment, errors, interface, locality, msd, order, parallel, plot, pmft, util. There is no ring or cycle module. order.py is Steinhardt, Hexatic, SolidLiquid, Cubatic, Nematic, RotationalAutocorrelation, and ContinuousCoordination. Ramasubramani and others, Comput. Phys. Commun. 254, 107275 (2020).

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

110592

1

8

8

20.7730

136.5008

6.5711

WIN

hexagonal 110592 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

110592

1

8

8

119.4383

503.1571

4.2127

WIN

hexagons 221184 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

110592

1

8

8

21.0405

2903.9205

138.0160

WIN

hexagonal 110592 equal

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

110592

1

8

8

19.2551

3006.8135

156.1569

WIN

q6_max_abs 5.551e-16

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

110592

1

8

8

116.2389

1327.4966

11.4204

WIN

hexagons 221184 equal

IRA

2.2.0

shape

110592

1

8

0

DNF

one sample exceeded 600 s | fit b=1.8826 se=0.0354 R2=0.999646 from 8000,13824,32768; extrapolated 110592 = 501919.9 ms. N^2 projection from 32768 is 585513.7 ms. The nine-size exponent is not used: the local exponent rises with N. Fit, not a measurement. classify_serial has no thread argument.

cycless

2.14.0/0.7

rings

110592

1

8

8

136.3856

341558.2557

2504.3573

WIN

hexagons 221184 equal; cycles_iter has no thread argument

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

110592

1

8

0

DNF

4096 molecules exceeded 600 s, so this size was not started

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

884736

1

8

8

82.4432

1140.5612

13.8345

WIN

pairs 1769472 equal

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

884736

1

8

8

102.7091

930.3372

9.0580

WIN

pairs 1769472 equal

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

884736

1

8

8

237.0502

1039.0684

4.3833

WIN

q6_max_abs 2.331e-15 q6bar_max_abs 2.331e-15

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

884736

1

8

8

237.9653

927.0447

3.8957

WIN

q6_max_abs 3.220e-15 q6bar_max_abs 3.220e-15

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

884736

1

8

8

203.1011

585.3079

2.8819

WIN

labels 884736 equal q6_max_abs 2.331e-15

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

884736

1

8

8

255.8396

38381.2306

150.0207

WIN

hexagonal 884736 equal rmsd_max 4.337e-08

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

884736

1

8

8

208.1052

1007.4027

4.8408

WIN

labels 884736 equal; analyze_waters parses JSON built once; chill.rs is a serial loop and Cargo.toml leaves rayon commented out; 0.3.18

freud

2.14.0

rings

884736

1

8

0

absent

freud 3.6.1 modules are box, cluster, data, density, diffraction, environment, errors, interface, locality, msd, order, parallel, plot, pmft, util. There is no ring or cycle module. order.py is Steinhardt, Hexatic, SolidLiquid, Cubatic, Nematic, RotationalAutocorrelation, and ContinuousCoordination. Ramasubramani and others, Comput. Phys. Commun. 254, 107275 (2020).

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

884736

1

8

8

248.1369

1136.5466

4.5803

WIN

hexagonal 884736 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

884736

1

8

8

1046.5149

4542.0060

4.3401

WIN

hexagons 1769472 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

884736

1

8

8

259.8032

23247.5896

89.4815

WIN

hexagonal 884736 equal

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

884736

1

8

8

240.7382

23208.5792

96.4059

WIN

q6_max_abs 6.661e-16

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

884736

1

8

8

1032.6158

13012.7347

12.6017

WIN

hexagons 1769472 equal

cycless

0.7

rings

884736

1

8

0

DNF

one sample exceeded 600 s | fit b=1.0193 se=0.0111 R2=0.999166 from 64,216,512,1000,1728,4096,8000,13824,32768; extrapolated 884736 = 2952280.4 ms. Fit, not a measurement. cycles_iter has no thread argument.

IRA

2.2.0

shape

884736

1

8

0

DNF

110592 molecules exceeded 600 s, so this size was not started | fit b=1.8826 se=0.0354 R2=0.999646 from 8000,13824,32768; extrapolated 884736 = 25162336.6 ms. N^2 projection from 32768 is 37472876.4 ms. The nine-size exponent is not used: the local exponent rises with N. Fit, not a measurement. classify_serial has no thread argument.

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

884736

1

8

0

DNF

4096 molecules exceeded 600 s, so this size was not started

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

chill_plus

8

8

0

absent

pyscal3 4.1.0 __all__ has no CHILL or CHILL+ name. common_neighbor_analysis is adaptive CNA and returns fcc, hcp, bcc, ico, and others (pyscal3/descriptors.py). diamond_structure is extended CNA. Neither is Nguyen and Molinero CHILL+. PyPI’s latest pyscal3 is this same 4.1.0.

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

4096

8

8

8

0.2509

0.5761

2.2961

WIN

pairs 8192 equal

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

4096

8

8

8

0.3054

0.8688

2.8444

WIN

pairs 8192 equal

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

4096

8

8

8

0.5273

0.8488

1.6098

WIN

q6_max_abs 4.441e-16 q6bar_max_abs 4.441e-16

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

4096

8

8

8

0.3900

1.9000

4.8712

WIN

q6_max_abs 5.551e-16 q6bar_max_abs 5.551e-16

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

4096

8

8

8

0.5076

0.5913

1.1649

WIN

labels 4096 equal q6_max_abs 4.441e-16

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

4096

8

8

8

0.2783

24.0122

86.2705

WIN

hexagonal 4096 equal rmsd_max 4.337e-08

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

4096

8

8

8

0.4711

4.5363

9.6285

WIN

labels 4096 equal; analyze_waters parses JSON built once; chill.rs is a serial loop and Cargo.toml leaves rayon commented out; 0.3.18

freud

2.14.0

rings

4096

8

8

0

absent

freud 3.6.1 modules are box, cluster, data, density, diffraction, environment, errors, interface, locality, msd, order, parallel, plot, pmft, util. There is no ring or cycle module. order.py is Steinhardt, Hexatic, SolidLiquid, Cubatic, Nematic, RotationalAutocorrelation, and ContinuousCoordination. Ramasubramani and others, Comput. Phys. Commun. 254, 107275 (2020).

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

4096

8

8

8

0.5566

1.9548

3.5122

WIN

hexagonal 4096 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

4096

8

8

8

2.6129

17.6346

6.7491

WIN

hexagons 8192 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

4096

8

8

8

0.5204

28.3374

54.4549

WIN

hexagonal 4096 equal

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

4096

8

8

8

0.6326

109.1420

172.5345

WIN

q6_max_abs 2.220e-16

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

4096

8

8

8

2.2476

12.5984

5.6052

WIN

hexagons 8192 equal

cycless

2.14.0/0.7

rings

4096

8

8

8

2.9191

12516.1838

4287.6594

WIN

hexagons 8192 equal; cycles_iter has no thread argument

IRA

2.14.0/2.2.0

shape

4096

8

8

8

1.2898

1299.2780

1007.3679

WIN

hexagonal 4096 equal

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

4096

8

8

0

DNF

512 molecules exceeded 600 s, so this size was not started

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

110592

8

8

8

4.0501

14.9654

3.6950

WIN

pairs 221184 equal

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

110592

8

8

8

3.8882

31.5433

8.1125

WIN

pairs 221184 equal

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

110592

8

8

8

5.3935

15.2391

2.8254

WIN

q6_max_abs 1.776e-15 q6bar_max_abs 1.776e-15

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

110592

8

8

8

5.3208

18.3291

3.4448

WIN

q6_max_abs 2.442e-15 q6bar_max_abs 2.442e-15

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

110592

8

8

8

7.5892

10.3904

1.3691

WIN

labels 110592 equal q6_max_abs 1.776e-15

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

110592

8

8

8

8.2662

613.5692

74.2262

WIN

hexagonal 110592 equal rmsd_max 4.337e-08

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

110592

8

8

8

5.2050

113.8816

21.8794

WIN

labels 110592 equal; analyze_waters parses JSON built once; chill.rs is a serial loop and Cargo.toml leaves rayon commented out; 0.3.18

freud

2.14.0

rings

110592

8

8

0

absent

freud 3.6.1 modules are box, cluster, data, density, diffraction, environment, errors, interface, locality, msd, order, parallel, plot, pmft, util. There is no ring or cycle module. order.py is Steinhardt, Hexatic, SolidLiquid, Cubatic, Nematic, RotationalAutocorrelation, and ContinuousCoordination. Ramasubramani and others, Comput. Phys. Commun. 254, 107275 (2020).

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

110592

8

8

8

8.3309

29.5160

3.5430

WIN

hexagonal 110592 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

110592

8

8

8

48.3409

323.8505

6.6993

WIN

hexagons 221184 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

110592

8

8

8

8.5196

387.5268

45.4867

WIN

hexagonal 110592 equal

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

110592

8

8

8

8.9858

3028.2786

337.0065

WIN

q6_max_abs 5.551e-16

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

110592

8

8

8

47.2318

307.1093

6.5022

WIN

hexagons 221184 equal

IRA

2.2.0

shape

110592

8

8

0

DNF

one sample exceeded 600 s | fit b=1.8826 se=0.0354 R2=0.999646 from 8000,13824,32768; extrapolated 110592 = 501919.9 ms. N^2 projection from 32768 is 585513.7 ms. The nine-size exponent is not used: the local exponent rises with N. Fit, not a measurement. classify_serial has no thread argument.

cycless

2.14.0/0.7

rings

110592

8

8

8

65.8726

337108.4778

5117.5843

WIN

hexagons 221184 equal; cycles_iter has no thread argument

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

110592

8

8

0

DNF

4096 molecules exceeded 600 s, so this size was not started

vesin

2.14.0/0.6.2

neighbours

884736

8

8

8

41.3136

209.6075

5.0736

WIN

pairs 1769472 equal

freud

2.14.0/3.6.1

neighbours

884736

8

8

8

49.5928

343.2560

6.9215

WIN

pairs 1769472 equal

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

q6

884736

8

8

8

71.0785

149.8983

2.1089

WIN

q6_max_abs 2.331e-15 q6bar_max_abs 2.331e-15

pyscal3

2.14.0/4.1.0

q6

884736

8

8

8

71.7527

177.4625

2.4733

WIN

q6_max_abs 3.220e-15 q6bar_max_abs 3.220e-15

mdapy

2.14.0/2.0.0

chill_plus

884736

8

8

8

66.4798

115.4407

1.7365

WIN

labels 884736 equal q6_max_abs 2.331e-15

PTM

2.14.0/162cc834

ptm

884736

8

8

8

59.6748

4823.9120

80.8367

WIN

hexagonal 884736 equal rmsd_max 4.337e-08

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

chill_plus

884736

8

8

8

59.4890

1008.0481

16.9451

WIN

labels 884736 equal; analyze_waters parses JSON built once; chill.rs is a serial loop and Cargo.toml leaves rayon commented out; 0.3.18

freud

2.14.0

rings

884736

8

8

0

absent

freud 3.6.1 modules are box, cluster, data, density, diffraction, environment, errors, interface, locality, msd, order, parallel, plot, pmft, util. There is no ring or cycle module. order.py is Steinhardt, Hexatic, SolidLiquid, Cubatic, Nematic, RotationalAutocorrelation, and ContinuousCoordination. Ramasubramani and others, Comput. Phys. Commun. 254, 107275 (2020).

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

identify_diamond

884736

8

8

8

62.1147

262.3612

4.2238

WIN

hexagonal 884736 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

rings

884736

8

8

8

484.2037

2917.3354

6.0250

WIN

hexagons 1769472 equal

OVITO

2.14.0/3.17.2

ptm

884736

8

8

8

63.6214

3062.3280

48.1336

WIN

hexagonal 884736 equal

PLUMED

2.14.0/2.10.0

q6

884736

8

8

8

91.1466

23631.1588

259.2655

WIN

q6_max_abs 6.661e-16

rings-statistics-matter

2.14.0/0.3.0

rings

884736

8

8

8

476.9637

2967.7415

6.2222

WIN

hexagons 1769472 equal

cycless

0.7

rings

884736

8

8

0

DNF

one sample exceeded 600 s | fit b=1.0193 se=0.0111 R2=0.999166 from 64,216,512,1000,1728,4096,8000,13824,32768; extrapolated 884736 = 2952280.4 ms. Fit, not a measurement. cycles_iter has no thread argument.

IRA

2.2.0

shape

884736

8

8

0

DNF

110592 molecules exceeded 600 s, so this size was not started | fit b=1.8826 se=0.0354 R2=0.999646 from 8000,13824,32768; extrapolated 884736 = 25162336.6 ms. N^2 projection from 32768 is 37472876.4 ms. The nine-size exponent is not used: the local exponent rises with N. Fit, not a measurement. classify_serial has no thread argument.

SQQ

0.5.8

cages

884736

8

8

0

DNF

4096 molecules exceeded 600 s, so this size was not started

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

46

1

8

8

0.5796

50.3899

86.9321

WIN

sI. 512 both 1 d-SEAMS-only 1 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 6 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0. 512-0 has 18 of 30 bonds across the periodic cell; the six 51262 cages have 10 to 15. The 5^12 TRACE returns has none. The 2x2x2 tile matches, so d-SEAMS is right.

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

46

8

8

8

0.5947

50.2893

84.5632

WIN

sI. 512 both 1 d-SEAMS-only 1 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 6 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0. 512-0 has 18 of 30 bonds across the periodic cell; the six 51262 cages have 10 to 15. The 5^12 TRACE returns has none. The 2x2x2 tile matches, so d-SEAMS is right.

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

368

1

8

8

3.7222

297.6070

79.9538

WIN

sI-222. 512 both 16 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 48 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0.

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

368

8

8

8

2.9243

297.9639

101.8907

WIN

sI-222. 512 both 16 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 48 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0.

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

136

1

8

8

1.4924

68.3007

45.7666

WIN

sII. 512 both 16 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 8 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0.

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

136

8

8

8

1.5655

68.2571

43.6016

WIN

sII. 512 both 16 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 8 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0.

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

1088

1

8

8

10.7150

697.6882

65.1132

WIN

sII-222. 512 both 128 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 64 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0.

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

1088

8

8

8

4.7284

697.7931

147.5752

WIN

sII-222. 512 both 128 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 64 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0.

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

110160

1

8

8

955.8314

61962.4841

64.8257

WIN

sII-9x9x10. 512 both 12960 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 6480 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0. TRACE is serial: analyze_waters has no thread argument and Cargo.toml leaves rayon commented out.

ClavisCage

2.14.0/0.3.18

cages

110160

8

8

8

303.0753

61956.9697

204.4277

WIN

sII-9x9x10. 512 both 12960 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 6480 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0. TRACE is serial: analyze_waters has no thread argument and Cargo.toml leaves rayon commented out.