CHILL+: the published rule and the OVITO rule

Nguyen and Molinero, J. Phys. Chem. B 2015, 119, 9369, equation 1 averages \(q_3\) over the four nearest neighbours of a shell that already holds four neighbours inside the cutoff. Table 1 gives the bond rows. A staggered bond is \(c(i,j) \le -0.8\). An eclipsed bond lies on \(-0.35 \le c(i,j) \le 0.25\). Those edges are closed. Footnote a of Table 1 is the neighbour test: two staggered bonds need a neighbour with more than two staggered bonds, and three staggered bonds with no eclipsed bond need a neighbour with more than one.

OVITO 3.17.2 averages \(q_3\) over the whole cutoff shell. Its staggered edge is the open cut \(c(i,j) < -0.8\), and the eclipsed band is open at both ends. The modifier skips the neighbour test in footnote a. ovito-chill+ in this tree is that rule. chill-plus with no --rule is the 2015 rule.

One oxygen from the liquid

input/chill-def/liquid-four-nearest.txt is an 18-atom piece of the TIP4P/ice liquid. The focus is atom 1, the second oxygen in the file. Its cutoff shell holds four neighbours. One of those neighbours has a fifth oxygen inside 3.5 Å, so the whole-shell average of \(q_3\) moves off the four-nearest average. None of the four correlations sits on -0.8, -0.35 or 0.25.

The published rule counts two eclipsed bonds and labels atom 1 water. ovito-chill+ counts three eclipsed bonds and labels atom 1 interClathrate. That is the one atom the fixture is built to move.

fixture focus 1 published water ovito interClathrate

The 4096-molecule liquid

On the 4096-molecule TIP4P/ice liquid, 250 of 4096 seed atoms differ between the published rule and OVITO 3.17.2. Every one of the 250 has four neighbours inside 3.5 Å. 235 of them change an eclipsed or staggered count because a neighbour has a fifth oxygen in the shell: that is the \(q_3\) average. The other 15 keep those bond counts and differ on the neighbour test alone. ovito-chill+ matches the OVITO modifier on all 4096 atoms. Ideal ice stays cubic under both rules.

How to select the rule

The command seams chill-plus takes --rule chill+ or --rule ovito-chill+. The command seams ovito-chill+ is the second of those.

seams chill-plus water.lammpstrj --cutoff 3.5 --type 1 --rule chill+
seams chill-plus water.lammpstrj --cutoff 3.5 --type 1 --rule ovito-chill+
seams ovito-chill+ water.lammpstrj --cutoff 3.5 --type 1

The same flags on the bundled ice Ih frame:

seams chill-plus input/traj/ice1h.lammpstrj --cutoff 3.5 --type 1 --rule chill+
seams chill-plus input/traj/ice1h.lammpstrj --cutoff 3.5 --type 1 --rule ovito-chill+
seams ovito-chill+ input/traj/ice1h.lammpstrj --cutoff 3.5 --type 1

The C call seams_chill_plus takes SEAMS_CHILL_PUBLISHED or SEAMS_CHILL_OVITO. seams_frame_chill_plus_rule takes the strings chill+ and ovito-chill+.

seams_chill_plus(sys, 3.5, 0, SEAMS_GRAPH_CUTOFF, SEAMS_CHILL_PUBLISHED, labels, counts);
seams_chill_plus(sys, 3.5, 0, SEAMS_GRAPH_CUTOFF, SEAMS_CHILL_OVITO, labels, counts);
seams_frame_chill_plus_rule(frame, 3.5, 1, "cutoff", "chill+", labels, counts);
seams_frame_chill_plus_rule(frame, 3.5, 1, "cutoff", "ovito-chill+", labels, counts);

Python is dseams.chill_plus. dseams.PUBLISHED is the 2015 rule. dseams.OVITO is the OVITO rule.

labels, counts = dseams.chill_plus(positions, box, rule=dseams.PUBLISHED)
assert len(labels) == 8 and int(counts.sum()) == 8
labels, counts = dseams.chill_plus(positions, box, rule=dseams.OVITO)
assert len(labels) == 8 and int(counts.sum()) == 8