Performance overview

A path under benchmarks/ on this page names a record of the d-SEAMS 2.0 benchmark campaign. The records and the Snakemake rules that write them are in the private paper repository and the Hugging Face dataset d-SEAMS/dseams2-benchmark-records (docs/records/README.md names the revision); the scripts under scripts/ that time a run stay here.

Four sittings sit next to each other. Every number on this page is from the frozen tables in docs/records, rendered from the benchmark records dataset. A ratio is the threads=1 median divided by the threads=8 median. The script marks a row flat when that ratio is between 0.95 and 1.05. A PLUMED row in the release-candidate table was measured on one thread because PLUMED_NUM_THREADS was unset. The 884736-molecule sitting sets that variable, so its PLUMED q6 row is timed at the width the column names.

file

what it times

benchmarks/rc3-sitting.csv

The release-candidate head-to-head, one thread and eight

benchmarks/trace-threads.csv

The hydrate signature search at 1, 2, 4 and 8 threads

benchmarks/paper-cells/sitting-large.csv

Ice Ic and a TIP4P/ice liquid at 884736 molecules, paired with freud, mdapy, vesin, pyscal3, PLUMED, OVITO and rings-statistics-matter at 1, 2, 4 and 8 threads, recorded at 2ed49e87

benchmarks/pool-audit.csv

The pool-sized kernels on ice Ic, retimed at 1ce3be3b

benchmarks/cutoff-rings.csv

The full cutoff ring call at 884736 molecules, linkcell against the cell list, recorded by cad887b2

The full tables are the release-candidate sitting, the thread controls, and the literature reproduction. meson test docs_sitting, docs_trace_threads, docs_pool_audit, and docs_sitting_large recompute the stored medians.

The same operation name is not the same call across files. rc3 \(q_4\) is the guest’s local parameter. The pool-audit file splits local and cutoff. The large-cell file names the call in its detail column. The tables keep the operation string the CSV stored.

The rings row in the large-cell file is the full cutoff call. It is seams_frame_rings: the cutoff list and the ring search together. The rings kernel in the pool-audit file is ringNetwork alone, and that timer starts after the neighbour graph exists. The two numbers are not interchangeable.

The large-cell detail column is the agreement check on the ice frame and on the TIP4P/ice liquid. q6 is compared with freud and with mdapy, and with pyscal3 and with PLUMED. On the liquid the freud gap is 1.525e-04, from hard-cutoff rounding, and the PLUMED gap is 1.679e-01, from the rational switch. CHILL+ on that liquid matches 830736/884736 molecules. The neighbour count is the directed pairs left by the cutoff list. d-SEAMS is compared with vesin and freud, and with pyscal3. OVITO coordination is the same pair sum. Both CHILL+ codes are compared on the cubic label. The classifier is compared with OVITO PTM restricted to the cubic and hexagonal diamond templates, where ice Ic is cubic diamond. The six-ring count is compared with rings-statistics-matter. PLUMED q6 in this file set PLUMED_NUM_THREADS. It is not the one-thread rc3 row.

Rendered from the four CSVs. ratio is the threads=1 median divided by the threads=8 median. flat means that ratio is between 0.95 and 1.05. A PLUMED row in the rc3 table says one thread; PLUMED_NUM_THREADS unset. Both of its columns were measured on one thread because that variable was unset. The large-cell PLUMED row set PLUMED_NUM_THREADS, so it is not that label.

What each file holds

file

rows

threads

molecules

rc3-sitting.csv

116

1 8

46 136 368 1000 4096 10648 21952 32768 64000 110592 884736

sitting-large.csv

208

1 2 4 8

884736

trace-threads.csv

32

1 2 4 8

368 1088 2944 8704 9936 23552 29376 69632

pool-audit.csv

128

1 2 4 8

4096 32768 110592 884736

rc3 sitting, one thread against eight

code

operation

molecules

t1_ms

t8_ms

ratio

with_threads

ClavisCage

cages

136

69.332

69.657

0.995

flat

ClavisCage

cages

368

301.514

302.471

0.997

flat

ClavisCage

cages

46

51.122

51.206

0.998

flat

OVITO

CHILL+

110592

622.424

88.685

7.018

falls

OVITO

CHILL+

884736

4890.789

666.288

7.340

falls

OVITO

PTM

110592

2790.624

370.341

7.535

falls

OVITO

PTM

884736

21304.364

2849.382

7.477

falls

OVITO

rings

110592

583.334

354.605

1.645

falls

OVITO

rings

884736

4883.899

2582.748

1.891

falls

PLUMED

q4

110592

1310.025

1316.423

0.995

one thread; PLUMED_NUM_THREADS unset

PLUMED

q4

884736

10053.680

10122.158

0.993

one thread; PLUMED_NUM_THREADS unset

PLUMED

q6

110592

1685.454

1680.281

1.003

one thread; PLUMED_NUM_THREADS unset

PLUMED

q6

884736

12947.767

12818.837

1.010

one thread; PLUMED_NUM_THREADS unset

d-SEAMS

CHILL+

110592

24.102

5.697

4.231

falls

d-SEAMS

CHILL+

884736

263.592

47.444

5.556

falls

d-SEAMS

PTM

110592

30.475

6.976

4.369

falls

d-SEAMS

PTM

884736

287.530

51.470

5.586

falls

d-SEAMS

cages

136

1.805

1.623

1.112

falls

d-SEAMS

cages

368

4.829

3.893

1.240

falls

d-SEAMS

cages

46

0.682

0.583

1.170

falls

d-SEAMS

neighbours

110592

28.325

6.453

4.389

falls

d-SEAMS

neighbours

884736

282.177

60.408

4.671

falls

d-SEAMS

q4

110592

23.747

6.094

3.897

falls

d-SEAMS

q4

884736

281.416

53.025

5.307

falls

d-SEAMS

q6

110592

25.832

5.820

4.438

falls

d-SEAMS

q6

884736

303.544

57.752

5.256

falls

d-SEAMS

rings

1000

1.019

1.087

0.937

rises

d-SEAMS

rings

10648

8.972

2.858

3.139

falls

d-SEAMS

rings

110592

86.531

32.665

2.649

falls

d-SEAMS

rings

21952

18.111

5.736

3.157

falls

d-SEAMS

rings

32768

26.227

8.816

2.975

falls

d-SEAMS

rings

4096

3.499

1.131

3.094

falls

d-SEAMS

rings

64000

49.326

16.147

3.055

falls

d-SEAMS

rings

884736

765.181

301.039

2.542

falls

fastatomstruct

king

1000

24.865

20.803

1.195

falls

fastatomstruct

king

10648

1813.620

306.073

5.925

falls

fastatomstruct

king

110592

572149.958

66413.885

8.615

falls

fastatomstruct

king

21952

16849.495

2166.371

7.778

falls

fastatomstruct

king

32768

47798.094

5787.638

8.259

falls

fastatomstruct

king

4096

289.722

109.916

2.636

falls

fastatomstruct

king

64000

189511.480

20791.598

9.115

falls

freud

q4

110592

276.580

51.302

5.391

falls

freud

q4

884736

2358.091

431.376

5.466

falls

freud

q6

110592

362.326

68.760

5.269

falls

freud

q6

884736

2973.372

550.161

5.405

falls

mdapy

CHILL+

110592

61.938

12.379

5.003

falls

mdapy

CHILL+

884736

744.487

125.578

5.928

falls

mdapy

q4

110592

64.687

12.400

5.217

falls

mdapy

q4

884736

807.101

96.238

8.387

falls

mdapy

q6

110592

79.232

14.572

5.437

falls

mdapy

q6

884736

921.574

107.347

8.585

falls

mdapy

rings

110592

2276.747

375.967

6.056

falls

mdapy

rings

884736

19221.718

3361.913

5.717

falls

rings-statistics-matter

rings

110592

1151.862

264.953

4.347

falls

rings-statistics-matter

rings

884736

11504.451

2665.750

4.316

falls

vesin

neighbours

110592

51.194

22.269

2.299

falls

vesin

neighbours

884736

1112.702

196.866

5.652

falls

884736-molecule sitting, one thread against eight

phase

code

operation

t1_ms

t8_ms

ratio

with_threads

ice

OVITO

chill+

4927.647

652.481

7.552

falls

ice

OVITO

coordination

287.170

58.378

4.919

falls

ice

OVITO

ptm-default

11787.795

1585.135

7.436

falls

ice

OVITO

ptm-ice

21901.041

2856.862

7.666

falls

ice

OVITO

q4

393.774

69.910

5.633

falls

ice

OVITO

q6

476.740

81.451

5.853

falls

ice

PLUMED

q6

15780.364

2864.697

5.509

falls

ice

d-SEAMS

chill+

235.591

45.688

5.157

falls

ice

d-SEAMS

classifier

204.002

48.499

4.206

falls

ice

d-SEAMS

neighbours

260.183

52.710

4.936

falls

ice

d-SEAMS

q4

144.664

31.895

4.536

falls

ice

d-SEAMS

q4+q6

319.346

85.776

3.723

falls

ice

d-SEAMS

q6

150.095

32.188

4.663

falls

ice

d-SEAMS

rings

662.186

246.607

2.685

falls

ice

freud

neighbours

1033.405

366.366

2.821

falls

ice

freud

q4

2164.249

457.446

4.731

falls

ice

freud

q6

2870.108

506.237

5.669

falls

ice

mdapy

chill+

580.057

93.155

6.227

falls

ice

mdapy

neighbours

469.862

88.871

5.287

falls

ice

mdapy

q4

698.390

111.528

6.262

falls

ice

mdapy

q6

803.702

134.511

5.975

falls

ice

mdapy

rings

18678.338

3447.121

5.419

falls

ice

pyscal3

neighbours

708.702

154.994

4.572

falls

ice

pyscal3

q6

956.332

185.698

5.150

falls

ice

rings-statistics-matter

rings

11267.173

2707.952

4.161

falls

ice

vesin

neighbours

1083.309

218.651

4.955

falls

liquid

OVITO

chill+

6997.797

1035.081

6.761

falls

liquid

OVITO

coordination

472.467

89.174

5.298

falls

liquid

OVITO

ptm-default

14735.477

2190.199

6.728

falls

liquid

OVITO

ptm-ice

23780.638

3494.725

6.805

falls

liquid

OVITO

q4

579.641

99.272

5.839

falls

liquid

OVITO

q6

678.298

112.396

6.035

falls

liquid

PLUMED

q6

14772.141

3248.878

4.547

falls

liquid

d-SEAMS

chill+

388.618

70.502

5.512

falls

liquid

d-SEAMS

classifier

231.571

63.954

3.621

falls

liquid

d-SEAMS

neighbours

358.812

70.649

5.079

falls

liquid

d-SEAMS

q4

286.448

51.916

5.518

falls

liquid

d-SEAMS

q4+q6

602.804

123.123

4.896

falls

liquid

d-SEAMS

q6

292.794

53.166

5.507

falls

liquid

d-SEAMS

rings

2942.271

677.074

4.346

falls

liquid

freud

neighbours

1432.248

562.501

2.546

falls

liquid

freud

q4

2704.072

621.275

4.352

falls

liquid

freud

q6

3476.079

693.877

5.010

falls

liquid

mdapy

chill+

939.828

168.668

5.572

falls

liquid

mdapy

neighbours

771.802

112.969

6.832

falls

liquid

mdapy

q4

971.259

148.271

6.551

falls

liquid

mdapy

q6

1132.685

178.443

6.348

falls

liquid

mdapy

rings

27579.640

5137.782

5.368

falls

liquid

pyscal3

neighbours

5676.788

4853.308

1.170

falls

liquid

pyscal3

q6

6518.490

4845.223

1.345

falls

liquid

rings-statistics-matter

rings

46036.912

7477.520

6.157

falls

liquid

vesin

neighbours

1208.267

249.099

4.851

falls

signature search, one thread against eight

crystal

cell

molecules

t1_ms

t8_ms

ratio

with_threads

sI

sI 2x2x2

368

1.671

0.889

1.879

falls

sI

sI 4x4x4

2944

11.155

5.296

2.107

falls

sI

sI 6x6x6

9936

34.513

11.407

3.026

falls

sI

sI 8x8x8

23552

79.231

26.431

2.998

falls

sII

sII 2x2x2

1088

4.815

2.544

1.893

falls

sII

sII 4x4x4

8704

35.908

11.174

3.214

falls

sII

sII 6x6x6

29376

121.799

31.094

3.917

falls

sII

sII 8x8x8

69632

292.810

73.109

4.005

falls

pool-sized kernels, one thread against eight

kernel

molecules

t1_ms

t8_ms

ratio

with_threads

chill

110592

24.159

5.275

4.580

falls

chill

32768

7.429

1.680

4.422

falls

chill

4096

0.908

0.349

2.600

falls

chill

884736

232.528

39.195

5.933

falls

hop

110592

26.382

7.194

3.667

falls

hop

32768

7.778

2.033

3.827

falls

hop

4096

0.979

0.381

2.565

falls

hop

884736

256.551

62.762

4.088

falls

q4-cutoff

110592

16.288

3.592

4.535

falls

q4-cutoff

32768

5.263

1.213

4.338

falls

q4-cutoff

4096

0.612

0.244

2.510

falls

q4-cutoff

884736

154.053

25.552

6.029

falls

q4-local

110592

20.345

4.051

5.022

falls

q4-local

32768

5.905

1.300

4.542

falls

q4-local

4096

0.667

0.263

2.538

falls

q4-local

884736

201.293

40.112

5.018

falls

q6-cutoff

110592

16.812

3.852

4.364

falls

q6-cutoff

32768

5.427

1.316

4.123

falls

q6-cutoff

4096

0.637

0.242

2.632

falls

q6-cutoff

884736

158.820

26.620

5.966

falls

q6-local

110592

23.795

4.614

5.158

falls

q6-local

32768

6.898

1.956

3.526

falls

q6-local

4096

0.772

0.392

1.970

falls

q6-local

884736

239.786

51.278

4.676

falls

rings

110592

62.012

13.538

4.581

falls

rings

32768

19.361

4.263

4.541

falls

rings

4096

2.467

0.634

3.892

falls

rings

884736

495.117

112.990

4.382

falls

symmetry

110592

24.393

6.161

3.960

falls

symmetry

32768

7.109

1.866

3.810

falls

symmetry

4096

0.913

0.415

2.202

falls

symmetry

884736

214.114

48.351

4.428

falls

Pool audit at 4096 molecules, four threads against eight

kernel

t4_ms

t8_ms

t8_over_t4

rings

0.941

0.634

0.674

q4-local

0.267

0.263

0.983

q6-local

0.380

0.392

1.029

q4-cutoff

0.243

0.244

1.005

q6-cutoff

0.230

0.242

1.052

chill

0.348

0.349

1.002

symmetry

0.415

0.415

1.000

hop

0.411

0.381

0.929

The 884736-molecule sitting

2ed49e87 is the sitting of ice and the TIP4P/ice liquid. One warm-up, then the calls stored in n, at 1, 2, 4 and 8 threads. Each width is its own process. The rivals are freud, mdapy, vesin, pyscal3 (neighbours and q6), PLUMED q6 with PLUMED_NUM_THREADS set to that width, OVITO (CHILL+, q4, q6, coordination, and PTM with the default templates and with only the diamond templates), and rings-statistics-matter. scripts/plot_sitting_large_time.py draws time against threads on a log axis, one panel per operation. The PDF is not stored. The tables recompute each median from the samples and carry the agreement notes. docs_table_csv checks the copied numbers. The rings row is still the full cutoff call. The separate cad887b2 table times that call with the cell-list builder.

Rendered from benchmarks/paper-cells/sitting-large.csv. Ice Ic and the TIP4P/ice liquid, 884736 molecules, at 1, 2, 4 and 8 threads. median_ms and iqr_ms are recomputed from samples_ms.

884736 molecules, rings

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

rings

1

8

662.186331

7.709950

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

rings

2

8

505.691531

2.180591

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

rings

4

8

322.999146

1.878734

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

rings

8

8

246.607390

2.603996

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

rings

1

8

18678.338048

36.697609

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

rings

2

8

10185.177415

264.167176

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

rings

4

8

5536.567612

23.633196

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

rings

8

8

3447.120831

94.535368

ice

rings-statistics-matter

0.3.0

rings

1

8

11267.172605

104.094082

ice

rings-statistics-matter

0.3.0

rings

2

8

6633.308637

177.403009

ice

rings-statistics-matter

0.3.0

rings

4

8

3959.606700

38.578481

ice

rings-statistics-matter

0.3.0

rings

8

8

2707.952381

45.784786

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

rings

1

8

2942.270905

22.955808

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

rings

2

8

1814.220889

51.021953

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

rings

4

8

998.383706

29.223032

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

rings

8

8

677.074304

20.849573

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

rings

1

8

27579.639817

171.815376

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

rings

2

8

16194.822290

130.023604

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

rings

4

8

8009.372364

17.513859

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

rings

8

8

5137.782209

33.329875

liquid

rings-statistics-matter

0.3.0

rings

1

6

46036.911696

77.316931

liquid

rings-statistics-matter

0.3.0

rings

2

8

26666.491281

544.907665

liquid

rings-statistics-matter

0.3.0

rings

4

8

13185.890586

433.594568

liquid

rings-statistics-matter

0.3.0

rings

8

8

7477.520378

191.312714

884736 molecules, q4

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

q4

1

8

393.774383

4.137814

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

q4

2

8

217.174148

0.787528

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

q4

4

8

115.909892

4.356892

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

q4

8

8

69.910496

2.243650

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4

1

8

144.664134

3.783138

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4

2

8

102.618623

1.205131

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4

4

8

51.169583

0.865751

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4

8

8

31.894543

0.986766

ice

freud

3.6.1

q4

1

8

2164.249095

8.713102

ice

freud

3.6.1

q4

2

8

1419.674984

84.838616

ice

freud

3.6.1

q4

4

8

784.121438

44.274944

ice

freud

3.6.1

q4

8

8

457.445690

30.630557

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

q4

1

8

698.390371

36.044986

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

q4

2

8

391.563470

5.272369

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

q4

4

8

194.412006

1.443060

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

q4

8

8

111.528206

1.200144

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

q4

1

8

579.640534

2.793886

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

q4

2

8

332.145158

4.860698

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

q4

4

8

165.699074

4.842977

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

q4

8

8

99.272471

2.021878

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4

1

8

286.448103

1.675933

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4

2

8

166.067812

1.540288

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4

4

8

77.947745

0.543349

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4

8

8

51.915775

2.394840

liquid

freud

3.6.1

q4

1

8

2704.071672

7.415644

liquid

freud

3.6.1

q4

2

8

1853.303502

156.008630

liquid

freud

3.6.1

q4

4

8

907.548228

56.902439

liquid

freud

3.6.1

q4

8

8

621.275455

26.823395

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

q4

1

8

971.259237

27.356182

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

q4

2

8

564.521305

4.611911

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

q4

4

8

250.628014

2.308852

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

q4

8

8

148.270544

0.931816

884736 molecules, q6

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

q6

1

8

476.740019

3.014938

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

q6

2

8

258.950219

1.378595

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

q6

4

8

138.717246

0.890053

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

q6

8

8

81.451371

0.853625

ice

PLUMED

2.10.0

q6

1

8

15780.364329

129.367822

ice

PLUMED

2.10.0

q6

2

8

9122.932280

77.942370

ice

PLUMED

2.10.0

q6

4

8

5127.090638

66.380703

ice

PLUMED

2.10.0

q6

8

8

2864.697461

66.352764

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q6

1

8

150.095376

8.041119

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q6

2

8

106.331635

1.090903

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q6

4

8

54.602033

2.024695

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q6

8

8

32.187543

0.626499

ice

freud

3.6.1

q6

1

8

2870.108465

63.217702

ice

freud

3.6.1

q6

2

8

1588.592745

38.430809

ice

freud

3.6.1

q6

4

8

856.659648

20.738859

ice

freud

3.6.1

q6

8

8

506.236844

14.845789

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

q6

1

8

803.702180

69.123959

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

q6

2

8

465.590425

15.851303

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

q6

4

8

234.623919

3.271774

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

q6

8

8

134.511059

0.683849

ice

pyscal3

4.1.0

q6

1

8

956.331838

24.719940

ice

pyscal3

4.1.0

q6

2

8

661.811874

19.488420

ice

pyscal3

4.1.0

q6

4

8

377.018574

8.627343

ice

pyscal3

4.1.0

q6

8

8

185.698144

9.797548

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

q6

1

8

678.297664

4.267453

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

q6

2

8

382.303237

4.449148

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

q6

4

8

188.867081

0.716456

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

q6

8

8

112.396025

4.454614

liquid

PLUMED

2.10.0

q6

1

8

14772.140906

438.636259

liquid

PLUMED

2.10.0

q6

2

8

9477.669487

352.180986

liquid

PLUMED

2.10.0

q6

4

8

5653.948207

321.456476

liquid

PLUMED

2.10.0

q6

8

8

3248.877521

90.966881

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q6

1

8

292.793704

0.728177

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q6

2

8

166.131269

6.112942

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q6

4

8

80.106488

0.814230

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q6

8

8

53.166358

6.388730

liquid

freud

3.6.1

q6

1

8

3476.078759

14.145887

liquid

freud

3.6.1

q6

2

8

2099.023623

65.504597

liquid

freud

3.6.1

q6

4

8

1040.515033

7.456540

liquid

freud

3.6.1

q6

8

8

693.877469

11.550832

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

q6

1

8

1132.684926

4.825046

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

q6

2

8

650.003788

7.289253

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

q6

4

8

298.040358

3.649716

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

q6

8

8

178.442670

4.018457

liquid

pyscal3

4.1.0

q6

1

8

6518.489819

329.088936

liquid

pyscal3

4.1.0

q6

2

8

5480.306716

378.482650

liquid

pyscal3

4.1.0

q6

4

8

5010.901699

132.053808

liquid

pyscal3

4.1.0

q6

8

8

4845.223172

254.819153

884736 molecules, q4+q6

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4+q6

1

8

319.346342

16.242020

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4+q6

2

8

229.616490

3.127563

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4+q6

4

8

127.765430

1.124273

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4+q6

8

8

85.776343

1.387195

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4+q6

1

8

602.804103

1.265489

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4+q6

2

8

368.866848

22.673677

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4+q6

4

8

176.934671

2.716631

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

q4+q6

8

8

123.122932

0.741609

884736 molecules, neighbours

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

neighbours

1

8

260.183255

2.815435

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

neighbours

2

8

111.843062

0.710481

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

neighbours

4

8

69.147587

0.690359

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

neighbours

8

8

52.710161

0.316257

ice

freud

3.6.1

neighbours

1

8

1033.404578

18.686047

ice

freud

3.6.1

neighbours

2

8

661.254477

4.615480

ice

freud

3.6.1

neighbours

4

8

455.454320

4.503258

ice

freud

3.6.1

neighbours

8

8

366.366447

3.658027

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

neighbours

1

8

469.861689

5.841553

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

neighbours

2

8

309.860069

4.307266

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

neighbours

4

8

152.080077

2.067547

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

neighbours

8

8

88.870961

0.538289

ice

pyscal3

4.1.0

neighbours

1

8

708.701885

19.232140

ice

pyscal3

4.1.0

neighbours

2

8

425.184906

6.443931

ice

pyscal3

4.1.0

neighbours

4

8

235.857468

1.198298

ice

pyscal3

4.1.0

neighbours

8

8

154.994385

5.714955

ice

vesin

0.6.2

neighbours

1

8

1083.309472

2.522056

ice

vesin

0.6.2

neighbours

2

8

622.438480

5.102668

ice

vesin

0.6.2

neighbours

4

8

325.512818

2.605657

ice

vesin

0.6.2

neighbours

8

8

218.650587

5.411048

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

neighbours

1

8

358.812312

4.186405

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

neighbours

2

8

170.156044

2.693297

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

neighbours

4

8

90.548790

3.518438

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

neighbours

8

8

70.648930

7.796123

liquid

freud

3.6.1

neighbours

1

8

1432.247512

54.820640

liquid

freud

3.6.1

neighbours

2

8

1030.021888

43.667224

liquid

freud

3.6.1

neighbours

4

8

603.890094

10.589945

liquid

freud

3.6.1

neighbours

8

8

562.501217

11.928904

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

neighbours

1

8

771.801758

3.058087

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

neighbours

2

8

429.869728

2.277783

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

neighbours

4

8

198.683425

2.303761

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

neighbours

8

8

112.968991

1.158516

liquid

pyscal3

4.1.0

neighbours

1

8

5676.787871

81.282883

liquid

pyscal3

4.1.0

neighbours

2

8

5603.882828

153.386654

liquid

pyscal3

4.1.0

neighbours

4

8

4754.237320

93.143985

liquid

pyscal3

4.1.0

neighbours

8

8

4853.308230

79.623149

liquid

vesin

0.6.2

neighbours

1

8

1208.267331

17.052754

liquid

vesin

0.6.2

neighbours

2

8

762.717040

11.745353

liquid

vesin

0.6.2

neighbours

4

8

378.252197

10.716701

liquid

vesin

0.6.2

neighbours

8

8

249.098881

6.795855

884736 molecules, coordination

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

coordination

1

8

287.170045

4.191347

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

coordination

2

8

145.636145

4.055686

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

coordination

4

8

85.381667

3.358684

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

coordination

8

8

58.378218

2.629528

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

coordination

1

8

472.466991

16.993577

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

coordination

2

8

233.463579

5.865690

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

coordination

4

8

142.570842

16.790352

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

coordination

8

8

89.174368

6.698092

884736 molecules, chill+

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

chill+

1

8

4927.647161

131.332798

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

chill+

2

8

2581.740603

89.800118

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

chill+

4

8

1255.920414

8.592690

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

chill+

8

8

652.481338

10.180414

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

chill+

1

8

235.590800

2.241617

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

chill+

2

8

145.024816

2.426909

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

chill+

4

8

74.371842

1.321772

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

chill+

8

8

45.687503

0.632083

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

chill+

1

8

580.057158

7.947656

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

chill+

2

8

332.859921

2.152168

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

chill+

4

8

140.905531

2.226631

ice

mdapy

2.0.0

chill+

8

8

93.155337

3.026722

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

chill+

1

8

6997.796508

16.235724

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

chill+

2

8

3834.721861

55.036084

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

chill+

4

8

1805.621600

17.508513

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

chill+

8

8

1035.080556

25.850869

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

chill+

1

8

388.617901

1.941140

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

chill+

2

8

227.415725

7.407150

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

chill+

4

8

110.300333

1.275771

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

chill+

8

8

70.501937

4.017953

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

chill+

1

8

939.828124

26.927838

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

chill+

2

8

552.703437

13.670375

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

chill+

4

8

265.714757

2.906239

liquid

mdapy

2.0.0

chill+

8

8

168.668110

4.805550

884736 molecules, classifier

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

classifier

1

8

204.001789

11.493721

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

classifier

2

8

141.623508

4.470199

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

classifier

4

8

76.617114

1.671496

ice

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

classifier

8

8

48.498846

1.722134

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

classifier

1

8

231.571034

1.257878

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

classifier

2

8

188.597390

9.855316

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

classifier

4

8

97.179141

3.084807

liquid

d-SEAMS

seams 2.14.0

classifier

8

8

63.953679

1.820939

884736 molecules, ptm-default

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-default

1

8

11787.794985

504.664867

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-default

2

8

6012.222311

128.504652

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-default

4

8

2980.834942

32.424211

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-default

8

8

1585.135363

34.661157

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-default

1

8

14735.477197

119.019972

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-default

2

8

8274.600159

496.794808

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-default

4

8

3835.197904

16.252276

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-default

8

8

2190.199007

47.743594

884736 molecules, ptm-ice

phase

code

version

operation

threads

n

median_ms

iqr_ms

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-ice

1

8

21901.040638

348.074319

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-ice

2

8

11691.448047

195.690409

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-ice

4

8

5522.668476

39.394348

ice

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-ice

8

8

2856.861712

22.979859

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-ice

1

8

23780.637982

166.045132

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-ice

2

8

13316.135075

289.690604

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-ice

4

8

6077.989898

31.866015

liquid

OVITO

3.17.2

ptm-ice

8

8

3494.724824

129.723371