ClavisCage TRACEΒΆ

h2h-summary.csv and h2h-clavis-cages.csv are copied from HaoZeke/seams-core branch bench/h2h-mdapy-pyscal3-vesin at 323bfd3872e726b3fa384a67c6b1bedf627ce6a0 (https://github.com/HaoZeke/seams-core/blob/323bfd3872e726b3fa384a67c6b1bedf627ce6a0/benchmarks/h2h-summary.csv). h2h-sqq.csv and h2h-sqq-agree.csv are copied from HaoZeke/seams-core branch bench/h2h-sqq at c7f71310f27c5ce62d11e97fd82f9757fa4e8628 (https://github.com/HaoZeke/seams-core/blob/c7f71310f27c5ce62d11e97fd82f9757fa4e8628/benchmarks/h2h-sqq.csv). docs/render_comparisons.py writes the Comparisons tables from these files.

One row per cell. The agreement column is the cage census parsed from h2h-clavis-cages.csv. The signature-by-signature rows are in the block below.

On the 46-molecule sI cell the census drops 7 cages that only d-SEAMS counts, and TRACE counts none that d-SEAMS does not. 512-0 has 18 of 30 bonds across the periodic cell; the six 51262 cages have 10 to 15. The 5^12 TRACE returns has none. The 2x2x2 tile matches, so d-SEAMS is right. On 110160 molecules, one thread, d-SEAMS takes 955.8314 ms and TRACE takes 61962.4841 ms. At eight threads d-SEAMS takes 303.0753 ms and TRACE takes 61956.9697 ms. TRACE is serial: analyze_waters has no thread argument and Cargo.toml leaves rayon commented out.

version

molecules

threads

cores

n

d-SEAMS ms

TRACE ms

ratio

agreement

2.14.0/0.3.18

46

1

8

8

0.5796

50.3899

86.9321

512 both 1 d-SEAMS-only 1 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 6 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

2.14.0/0.3.18

46

8

8

8

0.5947

50.2893

84.5632

512 both 1 d-SEAMS-only 1 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 6 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

2.14.0/0.3.18

368

1

8

8

3.7222

297.6070

79.9538

512 both 16 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 48 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

2.14.0/0.3.18

368

8

8

8

2.9243

297.9639

101.8907

512 both 16 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 48 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

2.14.0/0.3.18

136

1

8

8

1.4924

68.3007

45.7666

512 both 16 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 8 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

2.14.0/0.3.18

136

8

8

8

1.5655

68.2571

43.6016

512 both 16 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 8 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

2.14.0/0.3.18

1088

1

8

8

10.7150

697.6882

65.1132

512 both 128 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 64 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

2.14.0/0.3.18

1088

8

8

8

4.7284

697.7931

147.5752

512 both 128 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 64 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

2.14.0/0.3.18

110160

1

8

8

955.8314

61962.4841

64.8257

512 both 12960 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 6480 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

2.14.0/0.3.18

110160

8

8

8

303.0753

61956.9697

204.4277

512 both 12960 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51262 both 0 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0; 51264 both 6480 d-SEAMS-only 0 TRACE-only 0

Full cage-by-cage census

version

molecules

threads

cores

n

signature

both

d-SEAMS only

TRACE only

2.14.0/0.3.18

46

1

8

8

512

1

1

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

46

1

8

8

51262

0

6

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

46

1

8

8

51264

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

46

8

8

8

512

1

1

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

46

8

8

8

51262

0

6

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

46

8

8

8

51264

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

368

1

8

8

512

16

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

368

1

8

8

51262

48

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

368

1

8

8

51264

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

368

8

8

8

512

16

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

368

8

8

8

51262

48

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

368

8

8

8

51264

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

136

1

8

8

512

16

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

136

1

8

8

51262

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

136

1

8

8

51264

8

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

136

8

8

8

512

16

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

136

8

8

8

51262

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

136

8

8

8

51264

8

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

1088

1

8

8

512

128

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

1088

1

8

8

51262

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

1088

1

8

8

51264

64

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

1088

8

8

8

512

128

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

1088

8

8

8

51262

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

1088

8

8

8

51264

64

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

110160

1

8

8

512

12960

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

110160

1

8

8

51262

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

110160

1

8

8

51264

6480

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

110160

8

8

8

512

12960

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

110160

8

8

8

51262

0

0

0

2.14.0/0.3.18

110160

8

8

8

51264

6480

0

0