Choosing a cutoff and padding

The neighbour cutoff is the --cutoff of seams chill-plus. Open-face padding is the second-shell completion in the shell classifier. The validation compares that completion off and on. CHILL+ stays the published rule.

Leave the completion on when the bulk-liquid check records no added false positive. On an interface, read the layers whose label changed before treating the extra shell labels as ice. The classify timings are the same bulk liquid with the completion off and on.

A false positive is a non-negative shell label on an atom CHILL+ does not call cubic or hexagonal. dseams_off and fp_off are the classifier with the completion off. dseams_on and fp_on are the same frame with it on.

The rows are the cells of docs/data/recall-padding-validation.csv. That file is data/recall-padding-validation.csv written by scripts/recall_padding.py on science/interface-nucleation at 6ec9c283. Sphinx fills the tables from the file. A number that is not a cell of that file is not written.

The bulk-liquid gate

padding adds no false positive on the bulk liquid; the open-face completion stays on

False positives off are 0 and false positives on are 0.

Summary rows

Each row is one summary record. frame is the number of frames that row adds.

lane

temperature_K

frame

molecules

chill_ice

dseams_off

dseams_on

fp_off

fp_on

kind_changed

agree_off

agree_on

source

mw-bulk

230

10

40960

108

0

0

0

0

0

40852

40852

sum of the ten hold frames

mw-bulk

300

10

40960

19

0

0

0

0

0

40941

40941

sum of the ten hold frames

tip4p-basal

230

10

14640

9390

8491

8669

13

16

178

13715

13887

sum of the ten basal frames

T230_m0_r0_t0

230

1

1536

776

743

745

0

1

2

1503

1503

one pinned brine frame

T230_m0_r0_t1

230

1

1536

844

511

511

2

2

0

1199

1199

one pinned brine frame

T230_m0_r0_t2

230

1

1536

832

539

539

0

0

0

1243

1243

one pinned brine frame

T230_m0_r0_tend

230

1

1536

856

577

577

1

1

0

1255

1255

one pinned brine frame

T230_m20_r0_t0

230

1

1496

734

693

706

2

4

13

1451

1460

one pinned brine frame

T230_m20_r0_t1

230

1

1496

698

420

426

0

0

6

1218

1224

one pinned brine frame

T230_m20_r0_t2

230

1

1496

698

447

447

2

2

0

1241

1241

one pinned brine frame

T230_m20_r0_tend

230

1

1496

741

479

481

2

2

2

1230

1232

one pinned brine frame

T230_m40_r0_t0

230

1

1456

707

671

687

3

5

16

1414

1426

one pinned brine frame

T230_m40_r0_t1

230

1

1456

664

408

413

2

2

5

1196

1201

one pinned brine frame

T230_m40_r0_t2

230

1

1456

682

369

375

0

0

6

1143

1149

one pinned brine frame

T230_m40_r0_tend

230

1

1456

667

414

415

0

0

1

1203

1204

one pinned brine frame

Layers whose label changed

These are the layer records whose kind_changed cell is not 0. z_lo_A is the lower edge of the slab.

lane

frame

layer

z_lo_A

molecules

dseams_off

dseams_on

fp_off

fp_on

kind_changed

tip4p-basal

8

1

2.000000

128

20

33

2

2

13

tip4p-basal

8

14

28.000000

127

14

43

1

2

29

tip4p-basal

16

1

2.000000

128

41

43

1

1

2

tip4p-basal

16

14

28.000000

128

21

42

1

1

21

tip4p-basal

24

1

2.000000

128

51

52

0

0

1

tip4p-basal

24

14

28.000000

128

29

38

0

0

9

tip4p-basal

32

14

28.000000

127

26

41

1

1

15

tip4p-basal

40

14

28.000000

128

26

39

0

0

13

tip4p-basal

48

13

26.000000

1

0

1

0

0

1

tip4p-basal

48

14

28.000000

127

25

42

1

2

17

tip4p-basal

56

14

28.000000

127

24

38

1

2

14

tip4p-basal

64

1

2.000000

128

66

68

0

0

2

tip4p-basal

64

14

28.000000

126

22

32

1

1

10

tip4p-basal

72

14

28.000000

128

27

42

2

2

15

tip4p-basal

80

14

28.000000

128

23

39

0

0

16

T230_m0_r0_t0

1

0

0.000000

64

46

47

0

1

1

T230_m0_r0_t0

1

12

24.000000

64

52

53

0

0

1

T230_m20_r0_t0

1

0

0.000000

64

27

28

2

2

1

T230_m20_r0_t0

1

1

2.000000

64

61

62

0

0

1

T230_m20_r0_t0

1

11

22.000000

64

61

64

0

0

3

T230_m20_r0_t0

1

12

24.000000

64

30

38

0

2

8

T230_m20_r0_t1

1

0

0.000000

54

12

13

0

0

1

T230_m20_r0_t1

1

1

2.000000

47

18

19

0

0

1

T230_m20_r0_t1

1

2

4.000000

37

15

18

0

0

3

T230_m20_r0_t1

1

12

24.000000

54

16

17

0

0

1

T230_m20_r0_tend

1

0

0.000000

56

22

23

0

0

1

T230_m20_r0_tend

1

25

50.000000

69

4

5

2

2

1

T230_m40_r0_t0

1

0

0.000000

64

21

28

0

2

7

T230_m40_r0_t0

1

1

2.000000

64

61

64

0

0

3

T230_m40_r0_t0

1

11

22.000000

64

59

63

0

0

4

T230_m40_r0_t0

1

12

24.000000

64

18

20

3

3

2

T230_m40_r0_t1

1

2

4.000000

53

24

25

1

1

1

T230_m40_r0_t1

1

3

6.000000

61

48

49

1

1

1

T230_m40_r0_t1

1

12

24.000000

65

13

15

0

0

2

T230_m40_r0_t1

1

13

26.000000

65

0

1

0

0

1

T230_m40_r0_t2

1

0

0.000000

43

7

8

0

0

1

T230_m40_r0_t2

1

1

2.000000

45

10

13

0

0

3

T230_m40_r0_t2

1

13

26.000000

63

1

3

0

0

2

T230_m40_r0_tend

1

12

24.000000

64

18

19

0

0

1

Classify timings

padding is 0 when the open-face completion is off and 1 when it is on. seconds is one replicate.

molecules

padding

rep

seconds

cores_online

cores_affinity

cores_used

source

4096

0

1

0.000398

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

1

1

0.000389

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

0

2

0.000375

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

1

2

0.000370

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

0

3

0.000365

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

1

3

0.000367

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

0

4

0.000379

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

1

4

0.000384

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

0

5

0.000366

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

1

5

0.000375

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

0

6

0.000362

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

1

6

0.000367

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

0

7

0.000391

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

1

7

0.000396

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

0

8

0.000398

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

4096

1

8

0.000371

8

8

8

300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

0

1

0.039944

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

1

1

0.036897

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

0

2

0.041904

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

1

2

0.039008

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

0

3

0.040180

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

1

3

0.035358

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

0

4

0.034795

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

1

4

0.018831

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

0

5

0.009178

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

1

5

0.028915

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

0

6

0.028953

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

1

6

0.038089

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

0

7

0.020041

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

1

7

0.025629

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

0

8

0.031073

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame

110592

1

8

0.015290

8

8

8

3x3x3 tile of the 300 K bulk-liquid frame